The two contenders, side by side
Both oils sit in the prestige tier, both rely on argan as the hero ingredient, and both promise frizz control, shine, and heat protection. But the formulations, bottle sizes, and intended hair types diverge enough that picking the wrong one wastes a lot of money over a semester. Here is the practical comparison for the redken all soft argan 6 vs loreal mythic oil college budget decision:
| Feature | Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil | L'Oreal Mythic Oil Original |
|---|---|---|
| Bottle size | 3 fl oz (90 ml) | 4.2 fl oz (125 ml) |
| Typical 2026 MSRP | $42-$50 | $45-$55 |
| Per-ml cost | $0.55-$0.70 | $0.40-$0.50 |
| Key oils | Argan + 5 others (camellia, neroli, jojoba, olive, marula) | Argan + 5 others (sesame, almond, avocado, cottonseed, sunflower) |
| Best for | Dry, coarse, color-treated, very damaged | Normal-to-dry, fine-to-medium, frizzy |
| Heat protection | Yes, up to ~450°F | Yes, up to ~450°F |
| Scent | Sweet floral, lingering | Light powdery, fades fast |
| Drops per use | 2-3 for fine hair, 4-6 for thick | 3-4 for fine hair, 5-8 for thick |
| Months per bottle (3-4 washes/wk) | 3-4 | 4-6 |
| Silicone-forward? | Moderate (dimethicone, cyclopentasiloxane) | Heavy (cyclopentasiloxane, dimethiconol) |
If you're weighing the redken all soft argan 6 vs loreal mythic oil college budget question, here's the fast answer: L'Oreal Mythic Oil generally wins on price-per-milliliter at roughly $0.40-$0.50/ml versus Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil at $0.55-$0.70/ml, but Redken's six-oil blend tends to last longer per application on dry, coarse, or chemically processed hair. For a typical college student washing three or four times a week, a 4.2 oz bottle of Mythic Oil stretches four to six months; Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil's 3 oz bottle averages three to four months. Below we break down both formulas, ingredient decks, real per-use cost, and drugstore dupes you can pair with either to keep a luxury hair routine viable on a student stipend.
Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil: what you're actually paying for
Redken's pitch is right in the name: a blend of six oils, with Moroccan argan up top, formulated specifically for dry, brittle, and coarse hair that needs softening more than it needs polish. The viscosity is noticeably thicker than Mythic Oil, which is why two or three drops can saturate a fine ponytail but a thick, type-3 mane will happily eat five or six. That density is also why it disappears slower into the cuticle, giving you a longer-lasting slip when you're stretching a wash day to day four because your 8 a.m. lab ran late.
For a college budget, the math gets uncomfortable. A 3 oz bottle at the upper end of $50 lands at roughly $0.56 per ml. If you use 0.5 ml per application (about 4 drops) four times a week, that's ~$1.12/week or about $4.50/month in oil alone. Across a 9-month academic year you're at $40 plus tax, basically one full bottle. That isn't catastrophic, but it leaves zero margin if you also want shampoo, conditioner, and a hair mask in the same prestige tier.
Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil makes the most sense if your hair is bleached, chemically straightened, color-treated, or naturally coarse and the cheaper alternatives keep leaving you with that crunchy-then-frizzy mid-shaft feeling by lunchtime.
L'Oreal Mythic Oil: the broader-appeal player
L'Oreal Professionnel Mythic Oil Original was engineered as a salon do-everything serum — pre-blowdry primer, finishing polish, dry-ends rescue. The 4.2 oz size is the secret weapon for student wallets: you're getting 39% more product than Redken for roughly 10% more retail price. Cyclopentasiloxane sits high in the deck, which means the finish is glossier and the application feels lighter, but it also means buildup can happen faster on fine hair if you don't shampoo with a sulfate cleanser every 7-10 days.
The scent fades within an hour, which is actually a feature if you're sharing a dorm bathroom and don't want your perfume fighting your hair oil. Heat protection is real up to flat-iron temperatures, and the formula plays nice with the rest of L'Oreal's prestige and drugstore lineup if you ever need to step down to budget-tier luxury hair serums mid-semester.
The trade-off: Mythic Oil isn't going to reverse genuinely fried, bleach-damaged hair. It manages and styles. If your strands snap when you brush them, you need a bond repair product first and Mythic Oil second.
Per-use cost math for the average dorm routine
Let's run the actual numbers a student should care about. Assume a 16-week semester, four wash days per week, two applications per wash (mid-lengths post-shower, ends pre-styling).
- Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil: ~0.5 ml per application × 2 × 4 × 16 = 64 ml per semester. That's just over two thirds of a 90 ml bottle. Annualized: ~1.4 bottles, or roughly $63-$70/year.
- L'Oreal Mythic Oil: ~0.6 ml per application × 2 × 4 × 16 = 76.8 ml per semester. That's just over half a 125 ml bottle. Annualized: ~1.0 bottle, or roughly $45-$55/year.
Mythic Oil saves you roughly $15-$25 a year. That's a textbook rental or two dining-hall coffees a week. For a true redken all soft argan 6 vs loreal mythic oil college budget winner on pure dollars, Mythic Oil takes it — unless your hair type makes Redken's longer-lasting drops cancel out the price gap.
Drugstore dupes if both still feel too steep
Honest truth: a $45 oil isn't a college budget for many students. These three picks deliver 70-85% of the experience for a fraction of the cost, and you can rotate them with a smaller travel-size bottle of the prestige stuff for special occasions.
L'Oreal Paris Elvive Extraordinary Oil
This is the closest drugstore cousin to Mythic Oil from the same parent company — a six-oil blend (camellia, sunflower, linseed, almond, rose, coconut) in a 100 ml bottle that retails for roughly a fifth of Mythic Oil's price. The silicone load is heavier, so it builds up faster, but on fine-to-medium hair the shine and frizz control are remarkable for the money. Best as a daily oil with Mythic Oil saved for events and presentations. L'Oréal Paris Elvive Extraordinary Oil Miracle Hair Serum.
OGX Renewing + Argan Oil of Morocco Penetrating Oil
The closest you'll get to Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil for under $15. Cold-pressed argan headlines the formula and the dropper bottle (3.3 fl oz) gives you a similar application experience. Less complex than Redken's six-oil deck, so coarse hair may need more drops, but the cost per ml comes in around $0.13 — roughly a fifth of Redken's price. OGX Renewing + Argan Oil of Morocco Hair Oil.
HerStyler Hair Repair Serum with Argan Oil
A 2 fl oz argan-forward serum priced as a true impulse-buy, this is the dorm-drawer backup when your good oil runs out three days before your refill arrives. Lightweight, fast-absorbing, and forgiving on fine hair. Don't expect Redken-level conditioning depth, but as a daily flyaway tamer and heat-tool buffer, it punches above its tier. View on Amazon.
HASK Argan Repairing Shine Hair Oil Vials
The travel-vial format is genuinely useful for college students: each vial is one-use, so it survives a duffle bag and you can stash one in a backpack, gym bag, and dorm desk without committing a full bottle to each location. The argan/coconut formula leans glossy rather than deeply conditioning, so it's closer to Mythic Oil's finish than Redken's repair angle. HASK ARGAN Repairing Hair Oil Vials for shine and frizz control for all.
L'Oreal Paris Bond Repair+ Hair Oil-in-Serum
If your hair is genuinely damaged from box bleach, this drugstore hybrid is the smart spend. The oil-in-serum format gives you Mythic-style shine plus a citric-acid-based bond-strengthening claim that the original Mythic Oil doesn't make. Pair it with a once-a-week mask and you can defer the Redken purchase until summer. L'Oreal Paris Bond Repair+ Hair Oil-in-Serum.
Which one wins for your hair type?
The honest redken all soft argan 6 vs loreal mythic oil college budget verdict isn't a single answer — it's a matrix:
- Fine, normal-density hair, no color processing: Mythic Oil. The lighter viscosity and bigger bottle win.
- Medium-to-thick hair with mild dryness: Mythic Oil, paired with a weekly mask.
- Coarse 3B-4C texture or chemically straightened hair: Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil. The denser blend gives you more sealing per drop.
- Bleached, broken, splitting hair: Neither, on its own. Get a bond-repair serum first, then layer either oil over it.
- Genuinely broke and just want shine: OGX argan or Elvive Extraordinary Oil now; revisit prestige picks after winter break paychecks land.
For deeper context on matching oil viscosity to texture, see our guide to choosing a luxury hair serum by hair type, and if you're cross-shopping the Mythic Oil family specifically, our L'Oreal Mythic Oil vs Shu Uemura Essence Absolue comparison covers the next step up from Mythic Oil if you're ever in a position to splurge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil worth the extra money over L'Oreal Mythic Oil for fine, slightly damaged college hair?
Generally no. On fine hair, Redken's denser six-oil blend can read greasy and weigh roots down by day two. Mythic Oil's lighter silicone-forward profile sits better on fine textures and gives you 39% more product per bottle. Save Redken for coarse, color-bleached, or post-keratin-treated hair.
How long does a bottle of L'Oreal Mythic Oil actually last a college student?
Real-world: four to six months for a student washing three to four times a week and using three to five drops per application. Heavier users (daily heat styling, thick hair past the shoulders) will see four months. Light users with short pixie cuts can stretch a single 125 ml bottle past nine months.
Can I use Redken Argan-6 Oil and Mythic Oil on the same wash day?
Yes, and it's a smart trick for a tight budget. Apply Redken to wet mid-lengths and ends for the conditioning hit, then use a tiny drop of Mythic Oil on dry hair post-styling for the polished finish. This stretches the Redken bottle further because you're using less per application.
Will either oil cause buildup on color-treated hair?
Both contain silicones that can dull color if you clarify infrequently. Mythic Oil's higher cyclopentasiloxane load means it builds up faster, but it also rinses cleaner with a single sulfate-based shampoo. Redken's blend is heavier on natural oils, so buildup is slower but harder to fully strip. Either way, a clarifying wash every 7-10 days keeps color crisp.
What's the cheapest legitimate dupe for Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil under $20?
OGX Renewing + Argan Oil of Morocco Penetrating Oil is the closest single-product dupe. It's cold-pressed argan-forward, comes in a 3.3 oz bottle similar in size to Redken's 3 oz, and runs roughly one-fifth the cost per ml. You lose the camellia, marula, and neroli notes, but the core conditioning argan hit is genuinely close.
Does L'Oreal Mythic Oil work as a heat protectant for flat irons up to 450°F?
Yes, the formula is rated for thermal styling at standard flat-iron and blow-dryer temperatures. That said, no oil alone is a replacement for a dedicated heat-protection spray on bleached or compromised hair. For maximum protection, layer Mythic Oil over a water-based heat protectant on mid-lengths and ends.
If I can only buy one luxury hair oil for the whole school year, which should I pick?
For most students, L'Oreal Mythic Oil. The bigger bottle, broader hair-type compatibility, and lower per-ml cost make it the safer single-purchase. Only pick Redken All Soft Argan-6 Oil if you have specifically coarse, dry, or chemically processed hair that has consistently rejected lighter formulas — in which case the per-use efficiency of Redken's blend actually rebalances the math.
Key Takeaways
- Choosing the right redken all soft argan 6 vs loreal mythic oil college budget means matching the key features to your specific needs and budget
- Read real customer reviews and check the return policy before you commit
- Also covers: redken all soft vs mythic oil
- Also covers: argan 6 oil vs loreal mythic
- Also covers: best affordable luxury oil college
- Compare value across models — the priciest option is not always the best fit